Cayuga Island Homes for Sale

Welcome to Cayuga Island, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Niagara Falls, New York. This picturesque subdivision offers a unique blend of serene living and vibrant community spirit, making it an ideal choice for families, retirees, and everyone in between. With its lush greenery, scenic views, and proximity to the iconic Niagara Falls, Cayuga Island is a sanctuary that beautifully balances nature and convenience.

Cayuga Island boasts a variety of homes for sale, each showcasing distinct architectural styles and modern amenities. Whether you’re searching for a cozy bungalow, a spacious family home, or a charming cottage, you’ll find a diverse selection that caters to every taste and budget. Many properties feature generous yards, perfect for outdoor gatherings and enjoying the stunning sunsets that grace the area. With a strong sense of community, residents often come together for neighborhood events, fostering lasting friendships and a welcoming atmosphere.

Living in Cayuga Island means you’re just moments away from the breathtaking attractions of Niagara Falls, as well as local parks, shopping centers, and dining options. Outdoor enthusiasts will appreciate the nearby hiking trails and recreational activities that the region offers, ensuring that there’s always something to explore.

Don’t miss your chance to become part of this enchanting community. With homes for sale in Cayuga Island, your dream of a peaceful yet vibrant lifestyle is within reach. Embrace the charm of Cayuga Island and discover the perfect place to call home.

Newest Cayuga Island Homes for Sale

$220,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1691904 MLS

Attention water enthusiasts! Experience waterfront living on the Niagara River in this 1,092-square-foot Cape Cod offering direct water access with a private dock and boat slip, making it easy to enjoy boating, fishing, kayaking, and other water activities right from your backyard. A newly constructed seawall, completed at the end of 2024, enhances and protects the shoreline. The property also features a full, dry basement and offers the opportunity to enjoy the riverfront setting year-round. The home offers 2 bedrooms with an additional room that could serve as a third bedroom, office, or den, along with 2 full baths. The first floor features a bedroom, full bath, kitchen, and a living room with river views and a wood-burning fireplace. Upstairs you'll find a second bedroom, full bath, and additional flexible living space. Laundry is located in the basement, and all kitchen appliances, along with the washer and dryer, are included. Recent updates within the past two years include the furnace, central air, hot water tank, and sump pump. The roof is approximately 10 years old, and the interior and exterior have been freshly painted. Imagine stepping out your back door, boarding your boat, and exploring the Niagara River within minutes. Whether spending the day on the water or relaxing and taking in the views, this property offers the opportunity to enjoy waterfront living throughout the seasons.

8150 W Rivershore Drive, Niagara Falls

$370,000

5 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1670361 MLS

What a great value for a 5 bedroom, 2 full bath single family home at 9326 Rivershore Drive in Niagara Falls, NY - your perfect retreat on Cayuga Island. This inviting home is move-in ready and designed for enjoying your life to the fullest. The fully fenced backyard provides a private oasis ideal for relaxing, entertaining, grilling, gardening, or simply soaking up the sun. The covered patio is a bonus. Unwind in the enclosed sunroom, where you can enjoy peaceful views without the bother of mosquitoes. The first floor offers a flexible living arrangement, featuring a primary suite with a full bath or an ideal in-law suite for added convenience and versatility. 1st floor laundry The living room showcases a custom fireplace, creating a warm and inviting focal point, while the formal dining room with an indoor BBQ is perfect for gatherings. Upstairs, you’ll find 4 spacious bedrooms along with a full bath, offering plenty of room for everyone. The home also includes a partial basement with well-maintained mechanicals for added peace of mind. Recent updates enhance both style and comfort, including new flooring, updated lighting, fresh interior paint, a new hot water tank, central air, and improved exterior drainage. Parking is abundant, featuring a one-car garage, an attached carport, and additional space in the extended driveway. Also listed for rent ML# B1693871

9326 Rivershore Drive, Niagara Falls

Start Your Search