Grand Island Homes under $400,000

Grand Island Homes under $400,000

Welcome to Grand Island, New York—a hidden gem nestled in Erie County, where the beauty of nature meets the charm of suburban living. This picturesque island, situated on the Niagara River, offers a unique blend of tranquility and convenience, making it an ideal place for families, retirees, and everyone in between.

Grand Island is known for its lush parks, scenic waterfront views, and a strong sense of community. With easy access to both Buffalo and Niagara Falls, residents enjoy the best of both worlds—serene island living coupled with urban amenities. The island boasts a variety of recreational opportunities, including hiking trails, picnic areas, and boating on the river, perfect for those who cherish an active lifestyle.

For homebuyers seeking affordability without compromising on quality, Grand Island is an excellent choice. The real estate market features a range of homes priced under $400,000, offering exceptional value for first-time buyers and seasoned homeowners alike. From charming single-family houses to well-maintained townhomes, there’s something to suit every taste and budget. Many properties come with spacious yards, perfect for family gatherings or enjoying a quiet evening under the stars.

Living in Grand Island means embracing a vibrant community spirit, with local events and activities that bring neighbors together. Explore the local dining scene, shop at unique boutiques, or take part in seasonal festivals that celebrate the island’s rich heritage.

Discover your dream home in Grand Island, where affordability meets a lifestyle enriched by nature and community. Come experience the charm of this wonderful island—your new beginning awaits!

Newest Grand Island Homes under $400,000

1221 La Salle Avenue, Grand Island
$140,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1717816 MLS
Great opportunity to bring your vision to life with this 4 bedroom 2 full bath cape. First floor offers a large living room,eat in kitchen full bath and 2 bedrooms. The second floor features another full bath and 2 additional bedrooms. Convenient attached garage and a nice sized yard. This home is close to schools, public biking/walking paths and just a stones throw to the thruway.Price reflects the need for cosmetic interior remolding. Showings start immediately with offers due on 10/7th at noon. Square footage is approx.

1221 La Salle Avenue, Grand Island
1970 Baseline Road, Grand Island
$340,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1714618 MLS
History, character and remarkable versatility come together in this one-of-a-kind Grand Island home, situated on nearly one acre and offering more than 2,300 square feet of living space. Reported to be among the island's oldest surviving structures, the home has evolved into a creatively configured property filled with unexpected details. A generous living room flows through an open layout into an expansive dining room with space for an additional seating area. Beyond, the light-filled family room features a cathedral ceiling and wall of windows overlooking the deep backyard. Sliding glass doors open to a covered patio for a seamless connection to the outdoors. The substantial eat-in kitchen is equally distinctive, offering a vaulted ceiling, breakfast-bar peninsula, large center island, more than 20 feet of countertop space, extensive cabinetry and a built-in aquarium. Upstairs are two generously sized bedrooms, including a cathedral-ceiling primary with an exceptionally large walk-in closet, pull-down access to lofted storage and direct access to the spacious full bath. Here, a deep soaking tub, separate shower and updated vanity create a private retreat. A second full bath on the main level features an elegant tiled shower with custom glass enclosure, Corian-topped vanity and attractive flooring. An oversized rear foyer or mudroom provides additional storage and access to the basement, where partially finished walls, laundry space and a dedicated canning room offer further flexibility. Outside, the expansive yard extends toward undeveloped land and includes two detached garages, one with second-floor storage. Major improvements include a new architectural roof, new vinyl siding, vinyl replacement windows, updated furnace with central air and a newer high-efficiency water heater. Rich in history and filled with distinctive spaces, this extraordinary property must be experienced to be fully appreciated. Showings commence on Friday 9/18 at 4pm.

1970 Baseline Road, Grand Island
3383 Baseline Road, Grand Island
$359,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1714453 MLS
Discover a stunning 3-bedroom, 1.5-bath home in a prime Grand Island location within the desirable Grand Island School District. Situated on half an acre, this home features all bedrooms and a full bath on the second floor. The main floor offers an updated kitchen with soft-close cabinets, a dining area, and a cozy living room with a fireplace. The finished basement provides versatile space for recreation or a home office. Enjoy modern updates throughout, a spacious sunroom with sliding glass doors leading to a fully fenced yard, and a huge in-ground pool. Enjoy plenty of green space outside the fenced area, along with a convenient 1-car built-in garage. This home combines comfort and style with ample amenities.

3383 Baseline Road, Grand Island
3028 E River Road, Grand Island
$254,888
2 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ R1713957 MLS
Updated - 1720 sq. ft., 2-bedroom, 3-bath townhouse with a fully finished basement and a 1.5-car garage. $300/month maintenance fee ---Taxes approx. $5,000/year --- Beautiful two-story townhouse on the 18th hole of River Oaks Golf Course --- End unit with a picturesque setting, golf-course views, and a private patio --- Remodeled kitchen, hardwood floors throughout, and all appliances included, including a new washer and dryer --- Sliding glass doors open to a wood deck/patio surrounded by professionally maintained landscaping — ideal for relaxing or entertaining --- Full finished basement adds living space and storage. Attached 1.5-car garage. Located directly across East River Road from the Niagara River and marina --- Convenient Grand Island living with golf-course views and nearby water access --- Grand Island Central Schools --- Do not miss this well-maintained townhouse on one of the area’s most desirable courses ---The main home is 1220 sq. ft., and with the 500 sq. ft. finished basement, it's a total of 1720 finished sq. ft.

3028 E River Road, Grand Island
1295 E Park Road, Grand Island
$169,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1709570 MLS
Attention investors and owner-occupant handy folks! Welcome to 1295 East Park Rd in Grand Island. This 4-bedroom, 2-bath home is located in the quiet Grandyle Village neighborhood and offers nearly 1,600 sq. ft. of living space. Situated on a large corner lot with super-easy access to the I-190, the property features newer windows (2019), a new furnace and hot water tank, a 2-car garage with double-wide driveway, and a fully fenced yard. Price reflects the current condition of the home, making this a great opportunity for someone ready to bring their ideas and improvements to the property. Offers will be considered as submitted. Seller reserves the right to set an offer deadline at a later date.

1295 E Park Road, Grand Island
2640 Love Road, Grand Island
$229,500
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ B1708045 MLS
Charming country property, turn of the century one family home with wooded views and a rural feel. Enclosed screened front porch and open rear deck add to the quiet pleasure. Country kitchen opens to the dining room - a bright and pleasant space. The farmhouse ambiance is enhanced by two gas freestanding airtight stoves. Efficient lay out works like a ranch with two bedrooms and an updated spacious full bath with walk-in shower on the main floor. There are two additional rooms upstairs; one is a walk-through room and the other serves as bedroom 3. Erie County Health Department records show it as a four bedroom. Large detached two car garage and plenty of parking. Level lot offers many mature trees including a rare Horse Chestnut tree. If a homey farmhouse appeals to you, make sure you don't miss this one!

2640 Love Road, Grand Island
1551 Cox Road, Grand Island
$249,888
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1708658 MLS
OUTSTANDING OPPORTUNITY IN FERRY VILLAGE * FEATURES 4 BEDROOM 2 FULL BATHS * BRICK & SIDED CAPE COD HAS OVER 2100 SQ FT * W/ UPDATED 2018 ARC ROOF (TEAR OFF) ON HOUSE & ATTACHED GARAGE * DOUBLE WIDE DRIVEWAY * INTERIOR FEATURES * NICE SIZED LIVING ROOM * EAT-IN KITCHEN * (NEEDS UPDATING THROUGHOUT) STAINLESS APPLIANCES (AS-IS) INCLUDING REFRIGERATOR * STOVE/OVEN * DISHWASHER * ACCESS TO REAR COVERED PORCH * HOME HAS ENDLESS POSSIBILITIES * HAS 2 BEDROOMS AND FULL BATH ON 1ST FLOOR * 2ND FLOOR HAS 2 SPACIOUS BEDROOMS * 2ND FULL BATH * POURED CONCRETE BASEMENT * CENTRAL A/C * NICE YARD W/LARGE SHED (NOT FINISHED) SEE PRIVATE REMARKS!!! *

1551 Cox Road, Grand Island
1603 Love Road, Grand Island
$299,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1702957 MLS
Searching for a home in Grand Island, NY with a fenced yard, attached garage, updated mechanicals, and flexible living space? Welcome to 1603 Love Road, where classic Cape Cod charm meets modern comfort. Full basement for storage, hobbies, or future possibilities. With a new furnace and central air conditioning installed in 2025, you can enjoy year-round comfort from day one. Inside, you'll find a layout designed for both everyday living and entertaining. The spacious living room is anchored by a warm gas fireplace, creating an inviting place to gather on cooler evenings. The formal dining room features hardwood flooring and plenty of room for holidays and special occasions, while the generously sized kitchen offers abundant cabinetry, expansive counter space, and easy access to the bright sunroom. Filled with natural light, the sunroom provides a comfortable extension of the living space and overlooks the backyard, making it the perfect place to enjoy your morning coffee, read a book, or unwind at the end of the day. The first floor includes two comfortable bedrooms and a full bath, while the second floor serves as a private retreat with an expansive primary suite featuring its own full bathroom, walk-in closet, and sitting area—ideal for a home office, reading nook, or fitness space. Step outside to discover one of the property's standout features: a fully fenced backyard designed for enjoying every season. Whether you're hosting summer cookouts, gardening, relaxing with pets, or simply enjoying the outdoors, the yard offers both privacy and functionality. A convenient storage shed provides space for lawn equipment and seasonal items, while established berry bushes add charm and the enjoyment of harvesting fresh fruit right from your own backyard. The attached garage makes daily life easier by providing sheltered parking and additional storage, while the full basement offers exceptional utility space with laundry, mechanicals, and room for future projects or organization. 1603 Love Road is ready to welcome you home.

1603 Love Road, Grand Island
1361 Staley Road, Grand Island
$374,999
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1700519 MLS
Welcome home to this completely renovated three bedroom, one-and-a-half-bath ranch that perfectly blends modern updates with comfortable living. From the moment you arrive, you'll appreciate the attached one-and-a-half-car garage and the home's exceptional curb appeal, including the adjacent park like lot, adding to your outdoor recreational space. Step inside to discover a beautifully updated interior featuring new carpeting throughout, beautiful floors and a stunning eat-in kitchen complete with gleaming corian countertops, brand new appliances, plenty of cabinets and prep space- perfect for everyday living and entertaining. The spacious lower-level walkout offers an additional living area, providing endless possibilities for a home office or fitness area. Outside, your private backyard retreat awaits. Enjoy summer days relaxing by the in-ground pool, featuring a new liner and filter, or entertain family and friends on the expansive tri-level deck overlooking the beautifully designed outdoor space. With quality renovations throughout, generous living space and exceptional indoor and outdoor amenities, this move-in-ready ranch offers the perfect place to call home. Don't miss your opportunity to own this beautifully updated property. Showings begin on Sunday, July 26th. Open House on Saturday 8/22 from 11:00-1:00 PM. Offers will be reviewed when received.

1361 Staley Road, Grand Island
597 Alt Boulevard, Grand Island
$370,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1697224 MLS
Welcome to 597 Alt Boulevard. This Spacious and Turn Key Grand Island Ranch is ready for its new owner. Situated on 6.5 wooded serene acres and within walking distance to the West River. A maintenance free-vinyl exterior and double wide driveway that leads to an attached two car garage welcomes you to this special property. The large living room features a wood burning fireplace and flows seamlessly into a fully applianced eat-in kitchen with easy access to a convenience half bath and an inviting and bright family room. The family features a sliding glass door that provides access to the backyard patio. Three generous bedrooms and an updated full bath complete the main level. Original hardwood is underneath the living room and bedroom carpeted areas. The full basement offers potential for great additional living space and storage. Substantial capital improvements include updated windows, central air, architectural roof (2019), newer sump pump and hot water tank and sliding glass door (2019). Recent basement waterproofing was completed with a transferable warranty for even more peace of mind. Enjoy the outdoors on the stamped concrete patio overlooking the park like setting with mature landscaping, a variety of beautiful flowering plants and a thriving apple tree that produces an abundance of fruit each season. A great opportunity on the Island to make your new home!

597 Alt Boulevard, Grand Island
3542 Warner Drive, Grand Island
$229,900
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ B1698179 MLS
Terrific 3 bedroom Ranch Style home just steps away from Sandy Beach Yacht Club. Featuring a vaulted ceiling (living room) with exposed wood beam, formal dining room, eat-in kitchen and full basement (poured concrete foundation). Exterior boasts extra large rear deck with beautiful garden landscaping.

3542 Warner Drive, Grand Island
Start Your Search