Newstead Homes for Sale

Newstead Homes for Sale

Welcome to Newstead, a charming town nestled in Erie County, New York. Known for its picturesque landscapes and friendly community, Newstead offers a perfect blend of small-town charm and modern convenience.

If you are looking for homes for sale in Newstead, you are in the right place. Whether you are searching for a cozy bungalow, a historic farmhouse, or a modern family home, Newstead has a diverse range of real estate options to suit every taste and budget. From spacious properties with sprawling gardens to quaint homes with characterful features, there is something for everyone in this vibrant town.

With its close-knit community, top-rated schools, and easy access to amenities, Newstead is a sought-after location for families, young professionals, and retirees alike. Enjoy the tranquility of suburban living while still being within easy reach of the bustling city of Buffalo and the natural beauty of upstate New York.

Discover the perfect home for you in Newstead and experience the idyllic lifestyle that this charming town has to offer. Let us help you find your dream home in this welcoming community.

Newest Newstead Homes for Sale

$230,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1711399 MLS
Welcome home to this exceptional 3-bedroom, 2-full-bath home nestled in a wonderful neighborhood! This beautifully appointed property features hardwood floors, a convenient first-floor laundry, cozy fireplace, and a 2-car attached garage. The spacious, partially fenced backyard provides plenty of room to relax, entertain, or enjoy the outdoors. The finished basement adds a substantial amount of additional living space, making this home as functional as it is inviting. A fantastic opportunity in a great location!

21 Shepard Avenue, Newstead
$310,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1706570 MLS
Nestled in the Village of Akron, this home has been lovingly cared for by the same family for almost 60 years and is now ready for it's new owners! Entertaining and holidays made easy with a large family/dining room combo complete with beautiful natural woodwork including ceiling beams and a beautiful brick fireplace that is currently gas, but could be converted back to woodburning if the new owner chose. The kitchen has tons of counter and cupboard space along with a specially designed island that can either connect to the counter or be moved around as needed. First floor full bath and recently added first floor laundry for the win! Upstairs you will find 3 bedrooms, another full bath, huge primary bedroom with three closets (one cedar). Most of the windows have been replaced, the roof looks great, and there is a 3+ car garage out back complete with electric, overhead doors and a workshop. The basement is dry, has plenty of storage areas, glass block windows for security and regularly maintained mechanicals. All that plus it has an adorable covered front porch, good sized sun porch on the back of the home, private yard with no neighbors to the right and it's near the bike path for easy access. What more could you ask for except all appliances and window AC units will be included and there is currently no offer deadline! Come see for yourself what a wonderful home this is and make it yours!

40 Clinton Street, Newstead
$434,999
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ B1702046 MLS
Welcome to Your Private Oasis at 4762 S Ayers! 4 Bedrooms | 3 Full Bathrooms | 2,181 sq ft w/a 16x12 mudroom with first floor laundry adding an extra 192 sq ft bringing the total sq ft to 2,373! | Nearly 3 Acres | Ranch Style. Exceptional Single-Story Living: Welcome home to this stunning, meticulously cared-for ranch nestled on a private lot. From the moment you pull up, you’ll be impressed by the brand-new front landscaping and the eye-catching freshly stained 22' x 11' front deck—the perfect spot for your morning coffee. Bright, Modern Interiors: Step inside to discover seamless vinyl plank flooring running throughout the entire home, offering both modern style and easy maintenance. Chefs & Entertainers Delight: The oversized 26' x 10' galley kitchen features crisp white cabinetry, dynamic prep space, a generous breakfast bar, and all appliances. Sunken Family Rm: Unwind in the impressive 20' x 20' sunken family room, anchored by massive windows that flood the room with rich natural light. Thoughtful Floor Plan & Spacious Bedrooms: Designed with optimal privacy in mind, the floor plan smartly separates the bedrooms from the rest of the living space: Primary Suite: Features a full private en-suite bathroom and a dedicated 7' x 7' walk-in closet. Bedrooms: Located on the opposite side of the home away from the kitchen and family room, you’ll find 3 additional good-sized bedrooms served by a secondary full bath featuring a custom tiled-in shower. Backyard Retreat & Essential Amenities: The exterior grounds and bonus mechanical features make this property a rare find. Summer Ready: Dive into summer fun with your own private 36' x 16' liner pool right in the backyard. Garage & Mudroom: 3-car garage leads and mudroom complete w/first-floor laundry. Year-Round Peace of Mind: Equipped with a full-home generator to ensure comfort and power in any weather. Uncapped Potential Below: The massive full basement provides endless storage or a perfect blank canvas to finish for additional living space, a home gym, or a game room. A stunning well cared for property waiting for its next owner! Some photos virtually staged. Sellers reserves the right to set offer deadline date.

4762 S Ayers Road, Newstead
$499,999
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ B1703979 MLS
The one you've been waiting for: acreage and country living, minutes from the Village of Akron. Pride of ownership shows throughout this circa 1930 home. Extensively remodeled and updated in 2009, the home pairs period character with an open-concept kitchen, dining area, and family room that flow seamlessly from the original structure into the addition. The custom kitchen is outfitted with a matching stainless appliance package. Four bedrooms and two and a half baths. The primary bedroom is generously proportioned, with a recently updated custom en suite bath and a walk-in closet. A 24×19 bonus room above the family room offers flexible space for a home office, hobby room, or additional living area. Amenities include tankless hot water, gas forced air heat, and central air. Six acres in the Town of Newstead include 211 feet of road frontage, open ground, mature trees, and a pond. The rear property line opens onto the bike path and snowmobile trails, offering direct year-round recreational access. A detached garage and covered porch complete the exterior. The 40×40 pole barn is the standout: 1,600 square feet with power and water already run, suited to a workshop, equipment storage, or hobby space. Few properties offer this much country with the Village this close.

12869 Clarence Center Road, Newstead
$180,000
4 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ B1695812 MLS
Looking for a taste of country? Enjoy the view and peaceful setting of this 3.43 acre private country home. Minutes to stores and conveniences. Surrounded by farmland. Great school district. There have been updates on the siding, roof and windows. Ideal for the buyer to do some cosmetic updates and design the home to their own personal desire. First floor entry hall and laundry room adds convenience to the design of this home. Pellet stove for those chilly nights adds warmth and character to the living room. Storage room and walk in pantry adds convenience for organization. 2 story Barn has newer heating installed for working and being warm when the weather is cold. Barn also has garage door and carport. Land layout is great for ample parking, gardening and recreation. Enjoy the view from your covered front porch. Tax information was provided to me by the town.

12114 Meahl Road, Newstead
$550,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ B1695444 MLS
Welcome to your new custom-built modern farmhouse at 7394 Maple Road in the Town of Newstead! This brand-new 2026 construction home offers ~1,600 sq ft of thoughtfully designed living space on a spacious 1.4-acre rural lot (not wooded, with open usability). Served by highly rated Akron Central Schools, it’s perfect for anyone seeking peaceful country living with everyday convenience. Enjoy one-floor living with a first-floor primary suite featuring a private en-suite bath and spacious dressing room. The bright open eat-in kitchen boasts a large island—ideal for meals and entertaining. Highlights include first-floor laundry, 2.5+ baths, versatile upper bedrooms, and abundant natural light. Outside, the 1.4-acre rural lot offers privacy and room for gardening, play, or relaxation on the covered back patio. Built with modern amenities, energy-efficient features, and timeless farmhouse charm, this move-in-ready home delivers quality and value. In desirable Newstead with easy access to amenities, this property blends rural space and convenience. A rare opportunity from Marzec Homes! Tax shows 0 sq ft. Seller provided 1600 sq ft.

7395 Maple Road E, Newstead
$656,500
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ B1667617 MLS
Welcome to CMK Builder's stunning Zachary Model. Located in the highly desired Clarence School district, you'll find this 1,924 sq. ft. modern Colonial, thoughtfully designed with today’s lifestyle in mind. Offering 3 bedrooms with the potential for a 4th, this home blends timeless style with modern comfort in an open, airy layout. Step inside to find a bright and welcoming open floor plan, highlighted by a dramatic great room with cathedral ceilings and a beautiful gas fireplace with a cultured stone surround extending to the ceiling—the perfect centerpiece for relaxing or entertaining. The first floor features durable and stylish luxury vinyl plank flooring, along with a convenient half bath for guests. The kitchen is designed to impress, featuring your choice of quartz or granite countertops and KraftMaid soft-close cabinetry, allowing you to tailor the space to your personal style. Upstairs, you’ll find two full bathrooms, including a spacious primary suite with a private en-suite bath and walk-in closet, offering a peaceful retreat at the end of the day. Enjoy the added benefit of 8-foot ceilings on every level—including the basement, providing a sense of openness throughout and future finishing potential. Outdoor living is just as inviting with a generous 32’ x 5’ covered front porch and a 15’ x 15’ covered rear porch, perfect for enjoying quiet mornings or hosting gatherings. Additional features include a large 22’ x 22’ two-car garage with insulated doors and an up to 100' blacktop driveway, completing the home’s thoughtful design and curb appeal. This is a wonderful opportunity to own a beautifully crafted home that combines quality finishes, flexible living space, and classic charm. This is a "To Be Built Home", the floorplan can be adjusted to more meet your needs, other floorplans are available or can be created. Built with quality and efficiency in mind, the home includes Andersen windows, a high-efficiency furnace, 50-gallon hot water tank, and a durable 50-year architectural shingle roof. This is a rare chance to build a beautiful new home with quality finishes on a spacious lot located just steps from the bike path in a prime location.

11627 Clarence Center Road, Newstead
$650,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1665631 MLS
Well-maintained farm property in a prime location, just minutes from the Clarence Center Town Line. Perfect for a boarding or training facility, this property features 23 spacious horse stalls, a 7,200 sq ft indoor riding arena with a heated viewing room, and an expansive outdoor riding arena for complete horse training and equestrian activities. The residential home on site has been beautifully upgraded to blend rustic charm with modern living. The interior boasts extensive updates, including a fully renovated kitchen with premium countertops and stainless steel appliances, beautifully modernized bathrooms with contemporary tile work, and stunning new flooring throughout the expansive living spaces. This beautifully maintained interior offers high-end comfort alongside elite business amenities. The property previously generated strong rental income of up to $6,300/month. Behind the equestrian facilities lies a large parcel of land with excellent opportunities for future development, expansion, or agricultural use. Parcel boundaries were recently reconfigured, and an updated survey confirms the actual lot size is 10.73 acres. The adjacent properties at 13081 Main Rd and 13151 Main Rd are also currently available for sale. A rare opportunity for equestrian enthusiasts, investors, or buyers seeking land with development potential!

13123 Main Road, Newstead
$766,500
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ B1666562 MLS
Location Location Location! Meet CMK Builder's popular model, the "CAMERON". Welcome to your opportunity to build the home of your dreams on a beautiful 1.19-acre lot in the highly sought-after Clarence School District. This thoughtfully designed 2,402 sq. ft. home offers the perfect blend of comfort, style, and modern efficiency. Choose from one of the builder’s popular model plans or work together to customize the design to fit your own specifications. This spacious home features 3 bedrooms and 2.5 baths, including a first-floor primary suite with a large walk-in closet, offering convenience and privacy. The open floor plan creates an inviting atmosphere with a bright sunroom just off the kitchen, perfect for enjoying morning coffee or relaxing while overlooking the backyard. A first-floor den provides flexible space and could easily serve as a fourth bedroom, office, or study. The main living areas showcase luxury vinyl plank flooring, while the kitchen and bathrooms feature your choice of granite or quartz countertops and quality KraftMaid soft-close cabinetry. The living room is anchored by a gas fireplace with a cultured stone surround extending to the ceiling, creating a warm and elegant focal point. Additional highlights include 8-foot ceilings on every level—including the basement, tiled bathrooms, convenient first-floor laundry, and a basement egress window allowing for future finishing possibilities. Exterior features are equally impressive with a covered 12’ x 4’ front porch, covered 12’ x 15’ rear porch, 2-car garage with insulated door, and a 100-foot blacktop driveway. Built with quality and efficiency in mind, the home includes Andersen windows, a high-efficiency furnace, 50-gallon hot water tank, and a durable 50-year architectural shingle roof. This is a rare chance to build a beautiful new home with quality finishes on a spacious lot located just steps from the bike path in a prime location.

11591 Clarence Center Road, Newstead
Start Your Search