Marilla Homes for Sale

Marilla Homes for Sale

Marilla: A Charming Town in Erie County, NY

Nestled in the picturesque county of Erie, New York, Marilla is a delightful town that offers a peaceful and idyllic setting for its residents. With a population of just over 5,000, Marilla provides a close-knit community atmosphere where neighbors become friends and newcomers are always welcomed with open arms.

Marilla boasts a rich history that dates back to the early 19th century when it was first settled. Today, the town seamlessly combines its historical charm with modern amenities, making it an ideal place to call home. From quaint country roads lined with beautiful homes to sprawling farmlands and serene natural landscapes, Marilla offers a tranquil escape from the hustle and bustle of city life.

For those in search of their dream home, Marilla has an array of options to suit every taste and budget. Whether you're looking for a cozy cottage, a spacious family home, or a sprawling estate, the real estate market in Marilla has something for everyone. From charming historic properties to newly constructed houses, the homes for sale in Marilla are as diverse as its residents.

Living in Marilla means enjoying a peaceful lifestyle while still being within easy reach of urban conveniences. The town is conveniently located near major highways, providing easy access to nearby cities such as Buffalo and Niagara Falls. Residents can enjoy a variety of recreational activities, including hiking, fishing, and golfing, thanks to the abundance of parks and natural areas in the vicinity.

If you're seeking a place where community spirit, natural beauty, and a welcoming atmosphere come together, Marilla is the perfect choice. Discover the charm of this Erie County gem and find your dream home in this idyllic town.

Newest Marilla Homes for Sale

$499,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1697206 MLS
Nestled on 16.26 beautiful acres, this spacious ranch offers the privacy, tranquility & outdoor lifestyle you've been searching for! Enjoy a beautiful backyard overlooking your own pond, while the wooded acreage beyond is ideal for hunting, hiking, ATV trails & exploring nature right outside your door. Inside, you'll find a home filled with character & opportunity. The spacious family room (25' x 22') can fit any size sectional. It is truly the showpiece, featuring a massive floor-to-ceiling fireplace with an impressive mantle & walls of windows overlooking the property. While the living room contains exposed beams & brick flooring, a second fireplace creates another cozy gathering space, making this home perfect for entertaining & relaxing near the large back sliding door. The eat-in kitchen offers abundant cabinet storage, a peninsula, dinette space, an office nook & all appliances are included. The efficient ranch layout features 3 good size bedrooms with closets & a spacious full bathroom with 2 vanities back to back! Plenty of natural light throughout the home too. A drive-under attached garage leads to the full basement with exceptional storage, mechanics, workshop space & endless possibilities. Outside, you'll appreciate the large patio, mature landscaping, storage shed, rustic two story barn & wide-open yard to enjoy every sport season. Wrap-around balcony too! Whether you dream of fishing, hunting, gardening or simply escaping the hustle of everyday life, this property offers a lifestyle that's becoming increasingly difficult to find! This cherished family estate has been lovingly owned for generations & is ready for its next chapter. Being sold as-is, this is a rare opportunity to restore & personalize a truly special home on an unforgettable piece of land. If you've been searching for acreage, privacy & potential in Marilla, this is the one! Located in the Iroquois School District. Don't let this one pass you by.

2035 Eastwood Road, Marilla
$549,999
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ B1692801 MLS
Motivated Sellers!! East Aurora zip, Alden Schools and Marilla taxes. This 1840 Farmhouse was the original home of the first Marilla flower shop which is now the addition that has been completely reframed from ground up and gives you 330 sq ft of extra living space or open your own flower shop or bakery. Outside the doors of the addition there is a foundation that can be used for an additional deck or patio. Sitting on 8.9 acres this 4 bed 2 and a half bath home , is one of a kind. The owners completely renovated whole house from the metal roof to Heating and Ac. House has been fully gutted, reframed, electrical, plumbing, windows, siding, and spray foam insulation throughout. Kitchen has soft close cabinetry and beautiful leather granite counter tops. The home has an attached 2 car garage, large 42x30 pole barn with an additional 10x10 pool house. Walk out your back door to a 1200 sq ft barn with a brand new roof just installed! Looking for extra space? There is also a large loft above the barn consisting of a couch, fireplace, tv, and fridge for a nice extra hang out area for your kids and friends. Above ground pool only 2 years old, pond, fire pit, trails for atv, dirt bikes and open land for hunting, 2 beautiful apple trees and one blueberry tree. Driveway was done last year and both front and back stamped concrete patios as well only one year old. Addition outside will be completed before closing, inside is optional .All stainless-steel appliances, washer and dryer stay, furniture left in house or barn they willing to leave as well. Houses like this are hard to come by with large frontage, open land, corner lot, and amazing neighbors! Your families future Homestead awaits!!! Showings start immediately. Owners Relocated to NC but Still live in home. . Offers as they come in. Some of the photos are representations of finished addition and pond for visual use.

13151 Bullis Road, Marilla
$979,000
6 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ B1684357 MLS
Welcome to this STUNNING countryside retreat in Marilla, set on nearly 5 acres! This incredible farmhouse property offers over 4,500 square feet of versatile living space, including a full in-law setup, a rustic barn & breathtaking views in every direction. This one truly has it ALL! The inviting front porch greets you into a foyer with staircase leading to the main living area featuring 4 beds & 2.5 baths. The spacious LR showcases soaring vaulted ceilings & a cozy fireplace, while the formal DR offers beautiful views of the property. The fully remodeled kitchen is absolutely fabulous with included appliances, abundant cabinetry, island, quartz countertops & direct access to the balcony overlooking the entire property. The primary suite features an ensuite bath, walk-in closet & room for a king-size bed, while all 3 additional bedrooms offer generous closet space as well. A formal office, convenient laundry area, mechanic/storage space & an efficient floor plan throughout make everyday living effortless. The attached 2-car garage also includes a 2nd staircase leading to a large upper storage room. The first-floor in-law unit offers fantastic flexibility with 2 large bedrooms, 1 full bathroom, kitchen, living room, fireplace, one-step entry, private exterior egress & plenty of parking — ideal for multi-generational living, guest accommodations or investment potential. Overall, the property features 6 beds & 3.5 baths. Roof was just installed in 2025! Outside, the impressive barn is currently set up for animals with multiple stalls & pastures but offers endless possibilities for hobbyists, storage, workshops or future customization. Imagine enjoying your morning coffee while watching your horses right in your own backyard pasture. Horses, chickens & goats are allowed. With open green space, room to roam & picturesque rural beauty, this property is a dream setting for equestrian lovers or anyone seeking a peaceful, self-sustaining lifestyle. Board horses and/or rent the in-law for some extra income. Contingent & non-contingent buyers welcome! Square Feet as per Plans. Desirable Iroquois Schools too.

12286 Williston Road, Marilla
Start Your Search